Napster versus ReplayMusic
An interesting scenario has recently emerged: while the new Napster
allows you to download as many tracks as you want, and listen to them on your PC, and now, with Napster To Go, on any compatible devise, anytime you want [as long as you keep subscribing], the new Replay
Music boasts that it can take all these supposedly secured WMA files
and re-encode them into MP3s that you can own 'free and clear'.
This is from their website: "Replay Music captures MP3 files from both subscription music services and online radio stations. Every song is saved on your PC as a high quality MP3 file, automatically tagged with the artist, song title, album and genre, and perfectly separated into individual tracks. You can even burn songs directly to CDs. Plus, it's incredibly easy to use. What a great way to discover new music! What's Different about Replay Music? Unlike other recorders which just work with a few ShoutCast stations, Replay Music is the only product that works with both high quality online radio stations and popular subscription music services...."
Wow! I had people telling me that it works perfectly - as advertised ;) -, turning all
subscription services and even webcasters and online radio stations
into ... you guessed it, open celestial jukeboxes. MyMp3.com anyone? Now, you may argue, who would bother? Well, I checked on various use
groups and blogs - and a LOT of people do this now, in increasing
numbers. In fact, it is becoming a bit of an alternative to p2p
filesharing, and the web flows over with 'how-to' manuals on this stuff. Check out this dialog Now, the Replay Music people sell it for $50 - and there isn't much that can
be done to stop these kinds of software programs, since they are not per se infringing, imho. After all,
ProTools and Cool Edit and Sound Forge are recording tools, as well,
and can be used for this purpose (albeit less conveniently so). And of
course, Window's own RECORDER does the job just fine.
Right or wrong? Legitimate or illegal? Unfair? Let me hear your comments --- this is a hot subject.